
Up until this point, Doctor Fate's identity had not been revealed. Hope Starlin didn't have a big reveal planned this issue spoiled by the cover.
This issue begins with a dramatic countdown to the complete destruction of Earth. When the timer drops to zero and the world doesn't blow up, the Apokoloptian Dog Soldier and Gotham Policeman Joe Bester (both dead and both, I guess possessed by the Anti-Life Entity? No wait! The Dog Soldier must still be alive to protect Batman's Zero Kill Record) look at each other in confusion before Batman steps out of the shadows holding the unplugged cord from the bomb. Classic prank, Batman!

Batman left that dude a walking glory hole.
After saving the world yet again, Batman shoves a two ton piece of equipment onto the Dog Soldier. This pins him down because getting out from under two tons of steel is much harder than toppling two tons of steel, especially when it's shaped like a Jenga tower and Batman is the pusher of the two tons (with help from Forager who is probably pretty fucking strong himself). After that, they battle zombie cop Joe Bester. Batman seems to think going toe-to-toe with a character named "Bester" is a good idea. But it isn't a good idea because characters in fiction often have names that represent their personalities or physical attributes. Like how Batman is a man who dresses like a bat. And Forager is a Bug God that forages for New God scraps to keep his Bug Brothers alive. And Jack Tripper always trips over everything. And how Cheers' Sam Malone is a man who is alone. And James Incandenza from Infinite Jest works with optics and light and illuminates the thing that everybody can't live without, so much so that he probably destroys the world! What I'm saying is you can't defeat a fictional man named Bester! Only somebody named Bestest could defeat Bester but no writer is going to be so obvious as to name somebody Bestest!

Anyway Forager chops his head off or something.
Batman doesn't scold Forager about killing because Joe Bester was already dead and also why would Batman scold an alien about Earth hang-ups? Batman's way cooler than that uptight, Kryptonite-stick up his ass Superman.
Also it turns out Joe Bester was a robot. Um, what? Why? How? What the fuck? Did Editorial force that change? Batman already witnessed that Joe Bester was dead way back in Book One. Then Joe Bester's body disappeared along with the Dog Soldier's body. So why would it be a robot? Unless Jim Gordon is hiding some secret Gotham Robo-Police program!
After beheading the robot, Batman and Forager discover that Dog Soldiers actually don't have too much of a problem lifting two tons of machinery off of their prone bodies, especially when they're possessed by an Anti-Life Entity! The creature begins its renewed attack by knocking Forager unconscious. That means it's up to Batman to re-save the Earth that he didn't really just save a page or two back. But that's okay, right? Batman's like the greatest hero in the DC Universe! He can handle this thing!
Also it turns out Joe Bester was a robot. Um, what? Why? How? What the fuck? Did Editorial force that change? Batman already witnessed that Joe Bester was dead way back in Book One. Then Joe Bester's body disappeared along with the Dog Soldier's body. So why would it be a robot? Unless Jim Gordon is hiding some secret Gotham Robo-Police program!
After beheading the robot, Batman and Forager discover that Dog Soldiers actually don't have too much of a problem lifting two tons of machinery off of their prone bodies, especially when they're possessed by an Anti-Life Entity! The creature begins its renewed attack by knocking Forager unconscious. That means it's up to Batman to re-save the Earth that he didn't really just save a page or two back. But that's okay, right? Batman's like the greatest hero in the DC Universe! He can handle this thing!

Oh no! I think Batman comparing himself to a baby is like worst case scenario.
I was pretending to be confident about Batman's abilities because the truth is I already saw the back cover which shows Batman getting the life snuffed out of him by this creature.

The back covers of this series were probably the biggest reason I bought each issue. So clean!
So Batman blacks out or is killed or, I don't know, the scene changes as Batman Narration Boxes his death pretty matter-of-factly. It's how everybody always knew he would die minus his final cry of "Mom! Dad! I'm coming to join you!"
Meanwhile, Darkseid tries to absorb the power of Bob the Anti-Life Entity and discovers that he's not capable of doing that nor is he able to escape the Anti-Life dimension.
Meanwhile, Darkseid tries to absorb the power of Bob the Anti-Life Entity and discovers that he's not capable of doing that nor is he able to escape the Anti-Life dimension.

If this were a PG-13 movie, this the moment the one F-bomb allowed would be dropped.
So far, Bob the Anti-Life Entity hasn't really done much of anything. We only have Metron's paranoid memories as evidence that Bob even sent four of his fingertips into the DC Universe to destroy it. How do we know this large shadowy figure that hasn't moved one inch the whole time people have observed him wants to take over the non-anti-matter universe? He seems pretty chill to me.
Back on New Genesis, the heroes have discovered that Highfather, Darkseid, and Jason Blood are all missing. Their only clue as to why they are all missing is "Darkseid is an evil monster", but that doesn't really suggest any actions for them to take. So instead, they stand around saying, "John Stewart looks like he's going to kill himself." And Martian Manhunter is all, "Yeah, he's probably going to kill himself." Then they watch him walk off to, I guess, go kill himself?
Back on New Genesis, the heroes have discovered that Highfather, Darkseid, and Jason Blood are all missing. Their only clue as to why they are all missing is "Darkseid is an evil monster", but that doesn't really suggest any actions for them to take. So instead, they stand around saying, "John Stewart looks like he's going to kill himself." And Martian Manhunter is all, "Yeah, he's probably going to kill himself." Then they watch him walk off to, I guess, go kill himself?

Normally I might be upset seeing somebody on the verge of suicide but I just finished the final season of Squid Games and suicide has been normalized for me. Also maybe it's heroic?
I also just finished reading Infinite Jest in which suicide plays a major plot point (and also it's the book that a friend of mine who ultimately killed himself kept trying to finish for years) and I am reading Hamlet in which the title character is constantly saying shit like, "I'd kill myself but God has some kind of law against self-slaughter." So if John Stewart did kill himself, which he won't because he struggles with this Xanshi shit for years, it won't even register on my emotional EKG (which is currently just flatlined anyway. Thanks, fascist GOP and cowardly Dems!).
Batman was apparently exaggerating his death when he was all, "You hear that, Martha! I'm coming to join you!", because he's still conscious when his scene continues. Unbelievably, Batman is saved by Forager. I can't believe Forager was Jim Starlin's first choice for Batman's partner in this series. I can't even imagine he knew who the fuck Forager was! Forager saves Batman's life twice with his shield so I'm pretty sure Starlin turned in the script to DC and they sent back a note saying, "Hey, um, Jim? Re-read this note when you're not tripping balls, please? But, um, Captain America is a Marvel hero?" And Jim was all, "Well, I'm not changing the script. Who else has a shield?" And they were all, "The Guardian?" And Jim was all, "No, fuck that shit. Just give me some other random Fourth World character and give him a shield. That'll work. Also, is it okay if I have John Stewart hang himself with his power ring? Is that possible? Would the light construct noose disappear as soon as he passed out so he wouldn't die? Would the ring allow the wearer to kill themselves? Is suicide something DC wants to tackle in this big cosmic adventure? Can anybody on staff get me some 'shrooms from the West Coast?"
I should point out that I don't know that Jim Starlin was into psychedelics. But I also don't know that he wasn't so . . . ?
Forager goes down pretty quickly but he did his job; he saved Batman's life. So Batman rallies the troops and thinks, "Suicide is the only option!"
Batman was apparently exaggerating his death when he was all, "You hear that, Martha! I'm coming to join you!", because he's still conscious when his scene continues. Unbelievably, Batman is saved by Forager. I can't believe Forager was Jim Starlin's first choice for Batman's partner in this series. I can't even imagine he knew who the fuck Forager was! Forager saves Batman's life twice with his shield so I'm pretty sure Starlin turned in the script to DC and they sent back a note saying, "Hey, um, Jim? Re-read this note when you're not tripping balls, please? But, um, Captain America is a Marvel hero?" And Jim was all, "Well, I'm not changing the script. Who else has a shield?" And they were all, "The Guardian?" And Jim was all, "No, fuck that shit. Just give me some other random Fourth World character and give him a shield. That'll work. Also, is it okay if I have John Stewart hang himself with his power ring? Is that possible? Would the light construct noose disappear as soon as he passed out so he wouldn't die? Would the ring allow the wearer to kill themselves? Is suicide something DC wants to tackle in this big cosmic adventure? Can anybody on staff get me some 'shrooms from the West Coast?"
I should point out that I don't know that Jim Starlin was into psychedelics. But I also don't know that he wasn't so . . . ?
Forager goes down pretty quickly but he did his job; he saved Batman's life. So Batman rallies the troops and thinks, "Suicide is the only option!"

I understand giving your life to stop the end of the universe isn't technically suicide but I'm kind of stuck in a theme here.
Meanwhile in the Anti-Life Universe, Darkseid and Etrigan are about to become Anti-Life explosions when Doctor Fate suddenly appears and hauls them away from Bob the Anti-Life Entity. It feels like Darkseid's making a huge mistake hunting for the Anti-Life Equation when he should maybe just learn magic? Darkseid's willing enough to use magic in the pursuit of the most powerful scientific formula in the known universe because magic is more powerful than it. But he isn't willing to just use magic? What's his problem with magic? I suppose he doesn't like the often touted downside of magic where the user must sacrifice something for the powers they're given. But that doesn't seem any worse than what the fucking Anti-Life Equation asks for! The death of entire galaxies for ultimate power? Oh wait! I see. Darkseid's like a Conservative! He's not willing to sacrifice anything himself for gain; he's only willing to force others to sacrifice for his gain. What's one or two exploded universes in the grand scheme of things? Whereas if Darkseid were to start Constantining things up, he'd be losing personal shit right and left.

Doctor Fate isn't as good at rhyming as Etrigan. "Batman" and "Villain". "Quest" and "Left". Or maybe, some would suggest, he's better? Are half-rhymes more literary?
Alexander Pope would have preferred Doctor Fate's half-rhymes over Etrigan's basic bullshit rhymes, if I read The Dunciad correctly. Which I think I did and am not happy about. I can't quite put my finger on why but I fucking hated reading Pope. He felt like a smug asshole that didn't really have anything interesting to say. Maybe I was too dumb? Or too smug asshole myself?!
To rescue everybody from the Anti-Life Universe, Doctor Fate casts the spell "Cinque of Cosmic Power"! It takes the unique elemental source of power each of the five characters are linked to and gives them the power to return home. Although when he explains everybody's unique power, he sort of rushes past the whole "Highfather connects us to The Source, and, um, so does Orion!"
But to keep the Anti-Life Entity from following them and destroying their universe, Doctor Fate must destroy a universe between the Anti-Life Universe and the DC Universe. So, um, uh, wait. What? Doctor Fate just casually does to another what they're trying to prevent the Anti-Life Entity from doing to them? That's, um, fucking harsh, man. You're probably thinking, "Surely, he chose a barren universe that amounted to nothing that lay between the DC Universe and the Anti-Life Universe?" And I would answer, "Don't call me Shirley." Also I would point out this bit of narration as Fate destroys the universe:
To rescue everybody from the Anti-Life Universe, Doctor Fate casts the spell "Cinque of Cosmic Power"! It takes the unique elemental source of power each of the five characters are linked to and gives them the power to return home. Although when he explains everybody's unique power, he sort of rushes past the whole "Highfather connects us to The Source, and, um, so does Orion!"
But to keep the Anti-Life Entity from following them and destroying their universe, Doctor Fate must destroy a universe between the Anti-Life Universe and the DC Universe. So, um, uh, wait. What? Doctor Fate just casually does to another what they're trying to prevent the Anti-Life Entity from doing to them? That's, um, fucking harsh, man. You're probably thinking, "Surely, he chose a barren universe that amounted to nothing that lay between the DC Universe and the Anti-Life Universe?" And I would answer, "Don't call me Shirley." Also I would point out this bit of narration as Fate destroys the universe:

At least Doctor Fate points out he'll have some long and sleepless nights dealing with this act of possible (probable?) universal genocide.
Doctor Fate successfully strands the Anti-Life Entity in a prison of its own dimension. It's basically the plan Darkseid pretended he was going to enact with Etrigan but he was actually going to steal its power for himself. And thus ends the threat of Bob the Anti-Life Entity destroying the DC Universe!
Of course, there's still the matter of the Milky Way being completely destroyed if Batman and Forager don't stop their Anti-Life Entity! Its Doomsday Bomb might not allow Bob to enter the universe now but it will still destroy the entire Milky Way! The heroes on New Genesis are eager to rush off to help Batman when Superman points out that Earth is pretty big and there's no way anybody would be able to find them in time unless that person had, I don't know, Super Hearing or X-Ray vision or knew somebody who could run at the speed of light and search the entire planet? Too bad none of those things are possible and they're just going to have to leave it up to Batman! Which, on most days, I'd be all, "Whew! No problem then! Batman's got it covered!" But this day isn't like most days.
Of course, there's still the matter of the Milky Way being completely destroyed if Batman and Forager don't stop their Anti-Life Entity! Its Doomsday Bomb might not allow Bob to enter the universe now but it will still destroy the entire Milky Way! The heroes on New Genesis are eager to rush off to help Batman when Superman points out that Earth is pretty big and there's no way anybody would be able to find them in time unless that person had, I don't know, Super Hearing or X-Ray vision or knew somebody who could run at the speed of light and search the entire planet? Too bad none of those things are possible and they're just going to have to leave it up to Batman! Which, on most days, I'd be all, "Whew! No problem then! Batman's got it covered!" But this day isn't like most days.

Good job, Batman! You almost had him!
That might be three of my most favorite panels ever!
Meanwhile, everybody has forgotten about John Stewart and assume he's already dead. But maybe he's not! Maybe he'll use his ring to locate Batman and help save the day! Maybe that, at least, will help mitigate his guilt! Oh, and maybe he'll take Doctor Fate along since Fate's also feeling a bit guilty for probably killing one billion more times as many sentient beings as Stewart did.
In the end, Batman and Forager have to do it all themselves. Forager manages to get back on his feet and battle the Dog Soldier while Batman lies on the ground yelling at Forager to smash the Doomsday Bomb! So they essentially beat it together when Forager finally smashes his shield into the bomb, causing a much, much smaller explosion than anticipated. But still big enough to incapacitate the Dog Soldier and possibly kill Forager. Batman calls New Genesis to tell them the mission is a success and maybe send Green Lantern down to help clean up the mess? He'll start picking up the yellow debris.
Once the universe has been saved, J'onn finally decides to hunt down John Stewart and make sure he's okay. I mean, to make sure he's killed himself.
Meanwhile, everybody has forgotten about John Stewart and assume he's already dead. But maybe he's not! Maybe he'll use his ring to locate Batman and help save the day! Maybe that, at least, will help mitigate his guilt! Oh, and maybe he'll take Doctor Fate along since Fate's also feeling a bit guilty for probably killing one billion more times as many sentient beings as Stewart did.
In the end, Batman and Forager have to do it all themselves. Forager manages to get back on his feet and battle the Dog Soldier while Batman lies on the ground yelling at Forager to smash the Doomsday Bomb! So they essentially beat it together when Forager finally smashes his shield into the bomb, causing a much, much smaller explosion than anticipated. But still big enough to incapacitate the Dog Soldier and possibly kill Forager. Batman calls New Genesis to tell them the mission is a success and maybe send Green Lantern down to help clean up the mess? He'll start picking up the yellow debris.
Once the universe has been saved, J'onn finally decides to hunt down John Stewart and make sure he's okay. I mean, to make sure he's killed himself.


Jesus Christ, J'onn!
Obviously J'onn is a telepath so he knows exactly what John Stewart needs to hear to get him over the hump of this disaster and to start acting like a hero again. After John tells J'onn to fuck off and stomps away, J'onn just smiles the way I imagine anybody would smile if they knew telling somebody to go kill yourself was exactly the thing the person needed to hear to make them feel better.
In the epilogue, Orion calls the now dead Forager "Bug" in front of Batman and Batman punches him in the face. So Superman and Batman both got to beat up on Orion a little bit and Orion just takes it for some reason instead of blasting Batman's head off. And then the comic book ends with the lesson it was trying to teach us all along!
In the epilogue, Orion calls the now dead Forager "Bug" in front of Batman and Batman punches him in the face. So Superman and Batman both got to beat up on Orion a little bit and Orion just takes it for some reason instead of blasting Batman's head off. And then the comic book ends with the lesson it was trying to teach us all along!

Who went back in time to Pre-Woke 1989 to make this comic book woke?!
That was a joke about how comic books have always been about social justice and only stupid fucking assholes who think comic books are about punching people and stopping them from breaking laws that they themselves would never break. You can't feel judged if a hero stops a bank robbery when you haven't made bank robbery a huge part of your personality. But if a comic book hero says to the villain, "You're an intolerant asshole," some people suddenly feel judged for some reason!
Cosmic Odyssey: Book Four: Death Rating: B+. It loses a grade due to Doctor Fate basically doing what they were stopping the Anti-Life Entity from doing. It was somehow okay because it was either that universe of Doctor Fate's universe and Doctor Fate was all, "Nobody spends money buying comic books from that universe! It's okay to destroy that one!" I guess. I don't know. Anyway, don't call people slurs, guys!
Cosmic Odyssey: Book Four: Death Rating: B+. It loses a grade due to Doctor Fate basically doing what they were stopping the Anti-Life Entity from doing. It was somehow okay because it was either that universe of Doctor Fate's universe and Doctor Fate was all, "Nobody spends money buying comic books from that universe! It's okay to destroy that one!" I guess. I don't know. Anyway, don't call people slurs, guys!